| 2002 | 2003 | 2004 |
| Adam Benson, Sr. - RB/LB | Britt Haroldson, Sr. - Back | Tyler Holderby, Jr. - Lineman |
| Aaron Norgaard, Sr. - RB/LB | Adam Quail, Sr. - Back | Sam Minor, Sr. - Back |
| HM: Brandon Hope, Jr. | Brandon Hope , Sr. - Line | HM: Austin Knutson, Jr. |
| HM: Josh Renkly, Sr. | HM: Scott Colby, Sr. | HM: Burton Moe, Sr. |
| HM: Britt Haroldson, Jr. | HM: Tyler Nelson, Sr. | HM: Gary Utecht, Jr. |
| | HM: Derek Bass, Sr. | |
| 2005 | 2006 | 2007 |
| Tyler Holderby, Sr. - LB | Dane Adee, Sr. - RB | Aaron Chandler, Sr. |
| Austin Knutson, Sr. - OT | Tanner Bortnem | Ben Miller, Jr. - DL |
| HM: Josh Nelson, Sr. - QB | Dwight Pederson | Clint Hillestad, Jr. - DL |
| HM: Gary Utecht, Sr. - DT | HM: Aaron Chandler, Jr. - P | HM: Lane Docter |
| HM: Dwight Pederson, Jr. - WR | HM: Brooks Knolley | HM: Thor Vostad |
| | | HM: Levi Larsen |
| 2008 | 2009 | 2010 |
| Ben Miller - TE | Levi Larsen | Tyson DeGroot |
| Clint Hillestad - DL | Nathan Kramer | Garrett Schmidt |
| Tyler Christensen, Jr. | Brady Will | HM: Matt Hageman - OL |
| HM: Lance Johnson, Sr. | Tyler Christensen | HM: Austin Hall |
| HM: Brady Will , Jr. - WR | HM: Tanner Thompson-Moad | HM: Dane Larsen |
| HM: Nathan Kramer, Jr. - QB | HM: Jesse Schilling | |
| | HM: Taylor Docter | |
| 2011 | 2012 | 2013 |
| Matt Hageman - OL | Thayer Trenhaile | Cade Goodfellow |
| HM: Dan Mitchell | Trevor Lundin | Hayden Hall |
| | HM: Cade Goodfellow | HM: Trevor Lundin |
| | HM: Kyler Krogh | HM: Kyler Krogh |
| | HM: Tyler Tofte | HM: Cole Hauge |
| 2014 | 2015 | 2016 |
| Cole Hauge, Sr - DE | Brock Swartos, Sr. - RB/LB | Cadan Koerlin, Sr. |
| Hayden Hall, Sr - RB | Collin Kramer, Sr. - WR/S | Daymein Lucas, Jr. |
| Brock Swartos, Jr. - DE | Matt Larson, Jr. - RB/LB | Brennan Stoltenberg, Jr. |
| Andrew Goodfellow, Sr. - OL | HM: Nick Strasburg, Jr. - TE | HM: Silas Larsen, Sr. |
| HM: Matt Larson, So | HM: Chance Goodfellow, Jr. - OL/DE | HM: Cole Gross, Sr. |
| HM: Landon Stevens, Sr. | HM: Cadan Koerlin, Jr - C/LB | HM: Brayden Havrevold, So. |
| HM: Alec Bultje, So | | |
| 2017 | 2018 | 2019 |
| Daymein Lucas, Sr. | Dalton Hanson, Sr. | |
| Andrew Mullaney, Sr. | Brayden Havrevold, Sr. | |
| Brennan Stoltenberg, Sr. | Isaac Mittan, Sr. | |
| Jake Schneider, Sr. | HM: Jaxton Schiller | |
| Tyler Schwartz, Sr. | HM: Kashas VanderWal | |
| HM: Chase Ringheimer, Sr. | HM: Tayte White | |
| HM: Hudson Wagner, Sr. | | |
| HM: Brayden Havrevold, Sr. | | |