| Augustana College | | |
| 65-67: Charley Brown - Offensive Tackle | | |
| Brainerd Community College (1938-1995) NJCAA | | |
| 1992: Paul VanMaanen - WR/Punter | | |
| Dakota State College (1989 - 1988) NAIA | | |
| 1983: Mick Jensen, Class of 1983 - Running back | | |
| Dakota State University (1989 - Current) NAIA | | |
| 2002-2005: Jason Riechers - Class of 2002 - Linebacker | | |
| 2011-2013: Garrett Schmidt - Class of 2011, DB | | |
| 1999- ?: Adam Rud - Class of 1998 - Tailback | | |
| ? - Class of xxxx: Kellen Haroldson - | | |
| 2017- : Alec Bultje - Class of 2017 - WR #10 | | |
| Dakota Wesleyan University (1904-Present) NAIA | | |
| 2013: Dan Mitchell, Class of 2012 | | |
| 2013: Tyson DeGroot, Class of 2012 - Linebacker | | |
| 2014-2017: Trevor Lundin, Class of 2014 - Linebacker | | |
| 2018- :Daymein Lucas, Class of 2018 - Inside Linebacker #36 | | |
| Huron College (1897-1988) NAIA | | |
| 64-65: Dale Swartos - Linebacker or Fullback | | |
| 1983: Mark Swaney, Class of 1982 - Nose Tackle | | |
| Iowa Wesleyan University | | |
| 2019- : Dalton Hanson, Class of 2019 - Linebacker | | |
| Mayville State University NAIA | | |
| 2020- :Adam Dearduff, Class of 2020 - Defensive Line #66 | | |
| | | |
| Northern State College (1964-1988) | | |
| 69-70: Steve Swartos - Defensive Back | | |
| 1985-1986: Mick Jensen, Class of 1983 - Running back | | |
| Northern State University (1989 -Present) NCAA Division II | | |
| 1997-2001: Josh Graves - Class of 1997 - Tight End | | |
| 2018- : Tyler Schwartz, Class of 2018 - Linebacker #54 | | |
| Northwestern College (Orange City) (1961-Present) NAIA | | |
| 1975 - ?: Willis Kleinjan - Class of 1975 | | |
| 1999: John Sapp - Class of 1998 - Tight End #86 | | |
| South Dakota State College (1904-1951) | | |
| 32-33: Emerson Wolfe, Class of xx - Offensive Guard, Letterman 1932-33 | | |
| 34-35: Lyle Sundet, Class of xx - Letterman 1934-35 | | |
| South Dakota State College (1952-1963) & South Dakota State University (1964-1972) NCAA College Division | | |
| 58-59: Dennis Wolf - Class of xx, Letterman 1958-59 | | |
| 64-66: Bob Nelson, Class of xx, Letterman 1964-65-66 | | |
| 1965: Howard Hesby, Class of xx, Letterman 1965 | | |
| 65-67: Gene Vostad, Class of 64', Letterman 1965-66-67 | | |
| 66-67: Bryan Peeke, Class of xx - Linebacker, Letterman 1966-67 | | |
| South Dakota State University (1973-2007) NCAA Division II | | |
| 1983: Ryan Rohl, Class of 1982 - Defensive Back | | |
| 1983: Brett Revel, Class of 1982 - Wide Reciever | | |
| 84-87: Dan Ziegler, Class of xxxx- Defensive Safety, Letterman 1986-87-88 | | |
| 84-87: Darrin Thurston, Class of xxxx - Linebacker, Letterman 1985-86-87 | | |
| 89-93: Dan Nelson, Class of 1989 - Running back, Letterman 1991-92-93 | | |
| 90-93: Paul Swartos, Class of 1990 - Offensive Line, Letterman 1992-93-94 | | |
| 98-02: Kyle Haroldson, Class of 1997 - Linebacker, Letterman 1998-99-00-02 | | |
| 04-06: Britt Haroldson, Class of 2004 - Wide Receiver | | |
| South Dakota State University (2008- Present) NCAA Division I (AA/FCS) | | |
| 2013-2016: Thayer Trenhaile, Class of 2013 - Long Snapper, Letterman 2013-14-15-16 #56 | | |
| Wayne State College | | |
| 2020- : Layne Vander Wal, Class of 2020 - Wide Receiver, | | |
| Yankton College (1881-1984) NAIA | | |
| 1982: Don Swartos - Linebacker | | |
| 83 - ?: Tim Nelson, Class of 1982 - Slot Receiver | | |
| | | |